?

Log in

Lions tour only highlights Springbok deficiencies - Peter Bills [entries|archive|friends|userinfo]
Peter Bills

[ userinfo | livejournal userinfo ]
[ archive | journal archive ]

Lions tour only highlights Springbok deficiencies [Jul. 6th, 2009|11:18 am]
Peter Bills
[Tags|, ]

The 2009 Lions leave South Africa on Monday night, the Test series lost and yet, curiously, their concept re-invigorated.
 
No doubt partly due to South Africa's poor, dreadfully uneven performances during the Test series, the Lions escaped the 3-0 whitewash which an efficient, properly structured Springbok side would inevitably have inflicted. In the end, the Lions left bemoaning the fact that, but for a mere handful of points, a 2-1 series defeat could easily have been a draw or even a win.
 
No greater indictment of these misfiring Springboks exists than that fact. South African rugby has declined since the peak of the 2007 World Cup triumph.
 
Yet perhaps even more importantly, in the course of just six weeks, Lions coach Ian McGeechan and his colleagues repaired a great deal of the damage done to the Lions ethos by Clive Woodward's mad japes in 2005 in New Zealand. Now there's a thought, incidentally – imagine a Lions side coached by Woodward against a Springbok side coached by Peter de Villiers. Endless material for the men in white coats...
 
But significant factors still imperil the Lions. As Jeremy Guscott so rightly said last week "If the countries hosting the Lions do not give them proper respect by fielding as full strength sides as possible against them in the midweek games, then they place in peril the whole Lions idea."
 
Other elements have to change, too, for us to say with confidence the 2009 Lions' greatest achievement in future times will be seen to have restored the credibility of the brand. Not, mark you, the financial success of the brand; that is assured as long as tens of thousands of Brits and not a few Irishmen wish to splash their hard earned cash on the mother of all drinking sessions across the southern hemisphere for a few weeks every four years.
 
In Cape Town one night, one travelling Lions supporter splashed Rand 38,000 (approx. £3000) on a single bottle of French brandy. The bar manager's smile was still as wide as the Vaal river the next evening.
 
The onus here lies on the hosting unions. If, for example, Australia in four years time takes a similarly mercenary view of the tour as the South African rugby union of this one, then the future growth of the game will be actually stunted by the presence of the Lions.
 
I lost count of the number of people in Durban and Cape Town who told me that, lifelong rugby fans notwithstanding, they flatly refused to be fleeced by a greedy SARU charging European ticket prices in the southern hemisphere. So fathers refused to take kids to see the famous Lions….. How wonderful. Those at the top of South African rugby plus the Lions top brass if, as is alleged, they were in on the deal, should be ashamed of themselves for creating such a damaging trend in the game.
 
I wouldn't put it past Australia to do the same thing in four years time. But if the Lions concept is now little more than a cash bonanza for Australia, New Zealand and South Africa, let's finish it here and now. I'd rather just have the memories than be confronted with that sordid sight every four years.
 
But the Lions themselves need to learn lessons, too. They didn't get out enough to see a wonderful country with all its fantastic people, beautiful scenery and enchanting sights. Too many of them, too often sat in their rooms idling time away. For that, you have to look at the management and their obsession with training. They should have insisted the players went on more organised trips, met more strangers. A constant diet of non-stop training will turn potentially bright young minds into robots. That speaks ill of the great traditions of this game.
 
Other things need tweaking. 10 matches is too short, although the Lions suffered self inflicted wounds when McGeechan refused to give his 1st Test side a run-out the previous weekend. That was a crass mistake.
 
For me, the tourists need at least one more warm-up match and probably a further game, making it a 12-match tour. IF, that is, they are to be confronted by proper teams, not'B' sides. If that happens again, they should just fly in for Tests and fly out. Depressing yes, but inevitable. No-one wants to see a series of six or seven irrelevant mismatches that mean nothing.
 
As ever, you thank the host country for the memories. My favourite? Playing tag rugby last Friday morning with a group of local kids on a rough, scrubby field in the heart of Johannesburg's tough Alexandra township, in an event arranged by tour sponsors HSBC. On that occasion, five Lions did turn up and participate.
 
I'd suggest they shared my view that to see the smiles on the faces of children with so little and almost certainly with so much heartache and deprivation in their lives was simply priceless. That is and always was one of the best moments of Lions tours.
linkReply

Comments:
From: guy_harder
2009-07-06 10:57 am (UTC)

We still fail when it counts

The Boks are half the side they're capable of being. Our heroes, on the other hand, are celebrating a single victory out of three as if it makes up for everything. A shadow team of RWC winners, playing under a dire coach and showing the strain, still managed to beat us. Why is it so tough for a group of pros from four countries to 'gel' over six weeks and six matches? Is it any different when players from clubs and provinces around the world have to come together?! They don't get six weeks and six matches to get it right - we do and still fail most of the time.

In fact, this victory of theirs was more deserved than ours in '97 when we were completely outplayed in every department. If the Boks had converted their kicks in the second test in '97, they would've scored over 30 points! But do you notice how they didn't go on about ifs and buts, would'ves, could'ves, should'ves? That's all we've done! WE LOST! Well done Boks and good on John Smit for being immediately gracious in defeat on Saturday, unlike POC and BOD the two weeks prior.

The Boks may be in trouble but I'd rather be trouble and victorious, than courageous in defeat.

(Reply) (Thread)
From: caroline9
2010-11-15 09:29 am (UTC)

Re: AIR JORDAN SHOES

Black forced womens hoodies wholesale a fumble and recovered womens hoodies wholesale another as Toronto forced cheap hoodies five turnovers to upset mens hoodies Hamilton 16-13 in the cheap urban hoodies East Division semifinal hoodies wholesale Sunday to the dismay wholesale nike shoes of an Ivor Wynne wholesale nike shox Stadium gathering of 27,828.wholesale air max cb 94 Toronto, in the playoffs Shox R4-086 black & yellow for the first time wholesale nike air max 2009 since 2007, will face Montreal in the conference final next weekend. While the Alouettes will have home-field advantage,wholesale jordans shoes they did lose twice this ugg 5815 season to the upstart ugg 5825 Argos.Black’s recovery ugg 5803 of a Marcus Thigpen UGG Bailey Button 5803 fumble off a punt UGG Button Triplet 1873 return set up Toronto’s UGG Classic Short 5825 lone TD. Cleo Lemon’s UGG Classic Tall 5815 12-yard strike to Spencer UGG Classic Cardy 5819 Watt anchored a 10-point UGG Ultra Tall 5245 third quarter as UGG Classic 5854 the Argos erased a UGG Ultra Short 5225 6-3 halftime deficit UGG Classic Argyle Knit 5879 to lead 13-6 UGG Roxy Tall Boots while Hamilton starter UGG Roxy Tall Boots string Chocolate Kevin Glenn was being womens UGG Bailey Button chestnut treated for a knee womens UGG Classic Short black injury.“Turnovers UGG Bailey Button Triplet Chocolate are crucial in UGG Sundance II the regular season womens UGG Sundance II Chocolate and even more crucial UGG boots Sundance chestnut in the playoffs,”

from:http://www.ugg-boots-5825.com
(Reply) (Parent) (Thread)
From: caroline9
2010-11-15 09:22 am (UTC)

reply

UGG Bailey Button Kids Boot Gray said the unheralded UGG Women's Classic Short Chocolate second-year defensive back,black UGG Women's Classic Tall who received the Argos’UGG Classic Mini game ball afterwards.Chestnut UGG Women's Classic Mini “Our gameplan all UGG Women's Classic Cardy red week was to get ugg classic boot turnovers and give UGG Bailey Button our offence good (field) UGG Bailey Button Triplet position.“In the UGG Bailey Button playoffs field position UGG Bailey Button Triplet dictates the game.UGG Classic Short The defence has free Moncler Down Men reign when you pin Moncler Down Women (the opposing offence) deep.”UGG Classic Tall 5815 Glenn, one of just UGG Classic Cardy 5819 two CFL quarterbacks UGG Ultra Tall 5245 to pass for 5,000 yards UGG Classic 5854 this season, left late UGG Classic 5854 in the first half with UGG Classic Argyle Knit 5879 a hyperextended left knee.UGG Roxy Tall Boots He was injured after nike sb being hit by Toronto’s nike sb dunks Ricky Foley and walked Nike Air Yeezy womens off on his own wholesale nike air max 2011 red before running to Nike Air Max 2010 Mesh Black Orange the Hamilton bench nike shox silver late in the third.nike shox green “I haven’t seen it green nike shox but it was like he silver nike shox grabbed the back silver and green nike shox of my shoulder pads white nike shox gray and was trying to cheap wholesale air max's paypal drag me down,”

from:http://www.ugg-boots-5825.com
(Reply) (Thread)
From: caroline9
2010-11-15 09:28 am (UTC)

reply

Black forced womens hoodies wholesale a fumble and recovered womens hoodies wholesale another as Toronto forced cheap hoodies five turnovers to upset mens hoodies Hamilton 16-13 in the cheap urban hoodies East Division semifinal hoodies wholesale Sunday to the dismay wholesale nike shoes of an Ivor Wynne wholesale nike shox Stadium gathering of 27,828.wholesale air max cb 94 Toronto, in the playoffs Shox R4-086 black & yellow for the first time wholesale nike air max 2009 since 2007, will face Montreal in the conference final next weekend. While the Alouettes will have home-field advantage,wholesale jordans shoes they did lose twice this ugg 5815 season to the upstart ugg 5825 Argos.Black’s recovery ugg 5803 of a Marcus Thigpen UGG Bailey Button 5803 fumble off a punt UGG Button Triplet 1873 return set up Toronto’s UGG Classic Short 5825 lone TD. Cleo Lemon’s UGG Classic Tall 5815 12-yard strike to Spencer UGG Classic Cardy 5819 Watt anchored a 10-point UGG Ultra Tall 5245 third quarter as UGG Classic 5854 the Argos erased a UGG Ultra Short 5225 6-3 halftime deficit UGG Classic Argyle Knit 5879 to lead 13-6 UGG Roxy Tall Boots while Hamilton starter UGG Roxy Tall Boots string Chocolate Kevin Glenn was being womens UGG Bailey Button chestnut treated for a knee womens UGG Classic Short black injury.“Turnovers UGG Bailey Button Triplet Chocolate are crucial in UGG Sundance II the regular season womens UGG Sundance II Chocolate and even more crucial UGG boots Sundance chestnut in the playoffs,”

from:http://www.ugg-boots-5825.com
(Reply) (Thread)